Indian Journal of Research in Homeopathy

CLINICAL PAPER
Year
: 2014  |  Volume : 8  |  Issue : 1  |  Page : 37--41

A case of haemorrhoids in a 12-year-old boy


Padmalaya Rath1, Harleen Kaur2,  
1 Research Officer, Central Research Institute for Homoeopathy, Noida, Uttar Pradesh, India
2 Senior Research Fellow, Central Research Institute for Homoeopathy, Noida, Uttar Pradesh, India

Correspondence Address:
Padmalaya Rath
A 1/1, Sector 24, Noida
India

Abstract

Haemorrhoids is a very common condition that a physician would encounter in day to day practice. However, haemorrhoids in children is not as common. The only known treatment for the condition in conventional medicine is surgical excision, which is generally not favoured at this age. The case reported here is that of an internal haemorrhoids in a 12-year-old child, who was treated successfully with homoeopathic medicine. The patient has been observed for more than 2 years without recurrence. Photographs were taken before and after treatment to record changes in the condition. Non-recurrence of complaint in the past two and half years suggests that a «SQ»near permanent«SQ» cure is achievable through individualised homoeopathic treatment.



How to cite this article:
Rath P, Kaur H. A case of haemorrhoids in a 12-year-old boy.Indian J Res Homoeopathy 2014;8:37-41


How to cite this URL:
Rath P, Kaur H. A case of haemorrhoids in a 12-year-old boy. Indian J Res Homoeopathy [serial online] 2014 [cited 2019 Dec 13 ];8:37-41
Available from: http://www.ijrh.org/text.asp?2014/8/1/37/129677


Full Text

 Introduction



Haemorrhoids are enlarged veins located in the lower part of the rectum and the anus. External haemorrhoids originate below the dentate line, while internal haemorrhoids are above the line and are classified according to their degree of prolapse from the anal canal. [1] Haemorrhoids Grade I - are visualised on anoscopy, bulge into the lumen but do not extend below the dentate line, Grade II- prolapse out of the anal canal with defecation or with straining but reduce spontaneously, Grade III - prolapse out of the anal canal with defecation or straining, and require reduction, Grade IV haemorrhoids - are irreducible and may strangulate. [2],[3] It is important to differentiate a haemorrhoids from other growths like anal papillae or polyps. Polyps are usually asymptomatic but occasionally grow large enough to be felt by the patient or are likely to prolapse. Hypertrophied anal papilla, composed of a smooth mass located near the anal verge, is also considered a differential diagnosis especially in a patient with a history of chronic anal irritation or infection. [4]

About 75% of people will have haemorrhoids at some point in their lives. [5] Haemorrhoids is most common among adults aged 45-65. [6] About 80% of people in India develop haemorrhoids. and about 80% aged over 50 have some form of symptomatic haemorrhoidal disease. [7]

However, haemorrhoids in children are not as common. [8],[9] Some common symptoms include bleeding from the rectum, anal itching, general discomfort and an external anal protrusion. Children who are suffering from this condition should be treated quickly and monitored carefully in order to prevent the development of infections associated with the condition. Typically, when treated quickly and properly, haemorrhoids cause no lasting effects on the children. [10] In this case report we describe one such patient.

 Case Report



A 12-year-old boy presented with bleeding from anus since 3 years. Patient complained of some projection from anus, accompanied with bleeding during passage of stool. The patient reported of pushing up the protrusion by hand after daefecation. There was no history of pain. The patient did not take any prior treatment before reporting for homoeopathic medication. He had been advised surgery and the usual fear of surgery prompted his parents to seek homoeopathic treatment. Subsequently, the patient was brought to the OPD of CRI (H), Noida. On physical examination, position of haemorrhoids was found to be 11'O clock [Figure 1].{Figure 1}

The patient was non-vegetarian and of tall, lean built. His parents reported of his irritable nature and marked anxiety before examination at school. The patient was also observed to be anxious in general, a fact that was verified by his parents. His appetite was good and he desired both sweet and salty food items. He would also drink water frequently, about two glasses of water at a time. The boy was hot thermally, but also had a tendency to catch cold easily.

Family history: Mother - heavy menstrual flow

The following symptoms were considered for repertorisation:

AnxietyHot patientTendency to catch coldDesire for sweet and salted thingsThirst for large quantityHaemorrhoids protrudingHaemorrhoids protruding, stool duringHaemorrhoids bleeding.

The repertorial result that followed using Hompath Repertory (Classic M.D.) is shown in [Table 1].{Table 1}

A detailed account of the treatment is given below.

First Prescription (31.12.09)

Phosphorus 200/2 doses-OD *2 days

Placebo 30/BD *15 days

Advice: Sitz bath; restrict spicy and oily food.

Basis of Prescription

In terms of repertorial scoring, both Phosphorous and Sulphur scored 23/10 and Calcarea carb. scored 21/9. In this case, Phosphorous was preferred as it is a known anti-haemorrhagic medicine. It is prescribed for discharge of blood from rectum during stool, bleeding haemorrhoids [11] and also known to cover the symptom 'painless stool' well. Further, to confirm the prescription of Phoshorus over other drugs, a detailed cross-reference study was done. It was found that the rubric, 'Haemorrhoids protrude stool during' is an important one but not covered by Sulphur in Kent and Synthesis repertories and is covered only in 1 grade in Complete repertory. Another rubric, 'Haemorrhage from anus stool during' has three marks in Phosphorus and only one mark in Sulphur as per Synthesis repertory, while the same doesn't find a mention in any other repertory that was consulted. Calcarea carb. on the other hand, though scored 21/9 and two marks in 'haemorrhoids protrude during stool', the patient's physical appearance was not in consonance with the drug.

The follow up is mentioned in detail in [Table 2].{Table 2}

 Result



After prescription of Phosphorus in various potencies, the bleeding from haemorrhoids eventually stopped. However, there were a few intermittent episodes of bleeding before final cessation. Even the size of the protrusion reduced [Figure 2]. Later, in the due course of treatment, the haemorrhoids disappeared, as observed on 23 rd March 2011 and confirmed by surgeon on 27 th July 2011 [Figure 3]. Even after two years of stopping treatment, the patient has not reported of any recurrence. {Figure 2}{Figure 3}

 Discussion



Haemorrhoids in children, however uncommon, can result from unknown causes.

The disease, once established, tends to get worse over time. Medical application of creams and suppositories can relieve irritation and pain but rarely provide long-term benefit. A high fibre diet and bulk laxatives prevent constipation and worsening of the disease without achieving a cure. The mainstay of treatment is surgical. But unfortunately, operative haemorrhoidectomy is usually associated with significant postoperative complications, including pain, bleeding and anal strictures, which can result in protracted period of convalescence. Since surgery does not target the root causes like individual tendencies, habitual constipation, etc., recurrence is also common. Homoeopathic medicines can modify these tendencies, thus reducing chances of recurrence significantly. Homoeopathic literature mentions many medicines for the condition of which a similimum can help a patient for keeping the disease at bay for a longer period as evidenced in this case. Homeopathic remedies can offer gentle and safe relief. Patients have the highest satisfaction after taking the treatment. Mental makeup, physical makeup, sensations experienced by the patient, characteristics of haemorrhoids (bleeding, protruding, painful/painless), etc., also become a good tool for prescription. Besides, in a study on 78 patients between age group 25-60 years, homoeopathic medicines in LM potencies was found to be effective (P=0.0001) in treatment of internal haemorrhoids. This invites for further studies for evaluating the efficacy of the medicines in LM potencies in treating the condition. [14]

In this case, there was no history of repeated diarrhoea or intestinal infections that could have precipitated the development of haemorrhoids. Since there is no known precipitant for the condition, we may conclude that the difficulty was constitutional in origin and hence speaks of disordered susceptibility. A combination of lifestyle changes and homoeopathic treatment proved to be a great relief to this patient and also eliminated the need for surgery. A thorough homoeopathic treatment could remove the tendency and thereby prevent recurrence. Thus, the case also verifies the superiority of Materia Medica over repertory for correct choice of similimum. Phosphorus ultimately proved to be the correct choice as the first prescription, going by the result of the case. The dose 200 was selected in the beginning considering the severity of the case and the age of the child. However, it was increased to 1M when the bleeding recurred after stoppage even after two doses in 200 potency, which were allowed sufficient time to act. 1M potency was given with the hope that it would take the course of treatment further. Also, the size of mass did not reduce with the 200 potency. 1M was again repeated in due course, which finally also led to reduction and then final disappearance of the haemorrhoids. During the course of treatment, the patient once reported with diarrhoea, for which Aloes was given as an acute remedy. Sulphur was later given as an anti-psoric medicine to clear up the case at the conclusion. Proctoscopic examination by surgeon did not reveal any haemorrhoids or growth after treatment.

Although the case was successfully treated, a better compliance from the patient's side in terms of regular follow ups could have helped in quick recovery of patient. The patient was requested to show up regularly, but owing to the improvement in condition, the patient preferred to report only when his parents felt that the medication was needed. This led to long gaps in medication periods, but it did not seem to affect the case adversely.

 Conclusion



Homoeopathy can take care of chronic problems in an individual, where surgery is otherwise advised.Non-recurrence of complaint in past two and half years suggests that haemorrhoids can be treated successfully through individualised homoeopathic treatment. However, the results from this single case report are by no means conclusive regarding the long-term clinical effectiveness of homeopathy for haemorrhoids in children. Well designed studies are required for establishing effectiveness and efficacy of homoeopathy in treating the condition.

Editor's Note

While the results of Homoeopathic intervention are miraculous, explanations for the choice of the remedy are often complex and controversial. Also there are several alternative methods of posology and the timing for the introduction of homoeopathic remedies, the rules of which have not yet been clearly enunciated. For instance, when do we conclude that a particular patient is hot? What sort of data would justify such a conclusion? And which rubrics would accurately represent this thermal status? When do we conclude that the action of a remedy is over and the patient needs a complementary follow up remedy?. These aspects need to be researched to evolve a standardized homoeopathic treatment regime.

References

1Parker GS. A new treatment option for grades III and IV hemorrhoids Supplement to. J Fam Pract 2004;800.
2Banov L Jr, knoepp LF Jr, Erdman LH, Alia RT. Management of haemorrhoidal disease. J S C Med Assoc 1985;81:398-401.
3Parker GS, Mindy E. W Procedure for Prolapse and Hemorrhoids: A New Approach to a Gynecologic Dilemma; Supplement to OBG management; August 2005; S3-7.
4Gupta PJ. Hypertrophied anal papillae and fibrous anal polyps, should they be removed during anal fissure surgery? World J Gastroenterol 2004;10:2412-4.
5Baker H. Hemorrhoids. In: Longe JL, editor. Gale Encyclopedia of Medicine. 3rd ed. Detroit: Gale; 2006. p. 1766-9.
6Chong PS, Bartolo DC. Hemorrhoids and fissure in ano. Gastroenterol Clin of North Am 2008;37:627-44, ix.
7Treatment for hemorrhoids; the hindu; August 15, 2010. Available from: http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-features/tp-downtown/treatment-for-hemorrhoids/article571441.ece [Last accessed on 2013 May 27].
8Heaton ND, Davenport M, Howard ER. Symptomatic hemorrhoids and anorectal varices in children with portal hypertension. J Pediatr Surg 1992;27:833-5.
9Bartosh AM, Siubryts′ky MM. Combined hemorrhoids in early childhood. Klin Khir 1998;49-50. Available from: http://www.wisegeek.com/what-are-the-symptoms-of-hemorrhoids-in-children.htm [Last accessed on 2013 May 27].
10Available from: http://www.wisegeek.com/what-are-the-symptoms-of-hemorrhoids-in-children.htm [Last accessed on 2013 May 27].
11Willam B. Pocket manual of homoeopathic materia medica and repertory, Reprint edin. New Delhi: B jain Publisher; 2007. p. 507-11.
12Agbo SP. Surgical management of hemorrhoids. J Surg Tech Case Rep 2011;3:68-75.
13Karnalkar N. Hemorrhoids: Hygeia. J Drugs Med 2012;4:2.
14Chakraborty PS, Varanasi R, Majumdar AK, Banoth K, Prasad S, Ghosh MS, et al. Effect of homoeopathic LM potencies in acute attacks of haemorrhoidal disease: A multicentric randomized single-blind placebo-controlled trial. Indian J Res Homoeopathy 2013;7:72-80.